CompetitorsUS
CDK Global beats Tekion antitrust claims as franchise dealers hold 77% of US listings
With no monopoly finding, franchise dealers set DMS terms through competitive bids, and their used-car volume is where growth sits.

A federal judge in the US ruled for CDK Global on Tekion's monopolization and attempted monopolization claims, finding that CDK lacked monopoly power in dealer management systems (DMS). The buyers in that market are franchise dealers, who carried 5.04 million of the 6.58 million active US listings on Nov 16, 2026, about 77%, and whose used sales reached 1.03 million in Sep 2026, up 3% on Sep 2025, while new sales were flat.
The order was filed Nov 10, 2026 in the Northern District of California, and dailyjournal.com reported the ruling on Nov 12, 2026. It found that CDK's share of the franchise dealer software market stayed below 50% in 2023 and 2024. Under that finding, a dealer group with a grievance over price or contract terms has no monopoly ruling to lean on, and its leverage is a rival bid. The effect is largest for dealer groups heading into DMS renewals, which can seek competitive bids for contract terms rather than wait for regulatory relief.
Franchise dealers are the DMS buyers
MarketCheck data does not measure DMS vendor share, but it does size the channel the case is about. MarketCheck live inventory data for Nov 16, 2026 shows 5,039,216 active listings at franchise dealers, 76.6% of the 6,581,086 active listings across all US dealers. Independent dealers held 1,541,178, or 23.4%. The same car can appear on more than one site.
Used cars carry franchise volume growth
In MarketCheck sold-vehicle data from US franchise dealer websites, a sale is a listing leaving a dealer website and a price is an advertised asking price, a sold proxy.
| Franchise dealers, measure | New Sep 2025 | New Sep 2026 | New change | Used Sep 2025 | Used Sep 2026 | Used change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sold (units) | 1,191,963 | 1,195,098 | +0.3% | 992,335 | 1,025,954 | +3.4% |
| Median asking price ($) | 44,219 | 45,030 | +1.8% | 25,903 | 26,990 | +4.2% |
| Median miles | 5 | 5 | flat | 52,435 | 49,419 | -5.8% |
| Median days on market (days) | 43 | 43 | 0 days | 22 | 24 | +2 days |
| Mean asking price vs MSRP (%) | -3.57 | -3.29 | +0.28 pts | -34.51 | -34.26 | +0.25 pts |
Franchise dealers sold 1,025,954 used cars in Sep 2026 against 992,335 in Sep 2025 (+3.4%), while new-car sales were 1,195,098 against 1,191,963 (+0.3%). Sep 2026 counts are provisional and will rise slightly as late sales are detected. Dealers comparing systems will weigh appraisal, reconditioning and used pricing workflows more heavily than new-car desking.
Used cars at franchise dealers are listed higher and sit longer. The median asking price for franchise used sales rose 4% to $26,990, from $25,903, while median miles fell from 52,435 to 49,419, so younger cars account for part of that rise alongside higher asking prices for the same car. Median days on market rose from 22 to 24, and longer holding periods raise the value of pricing and inventory integrations for dealers. Price and miles figures are medians, and the comparison with MSRP is mean-based.
New-car asking prices held close to MSRP, and the channel is discounting no more than it did in Sep 2025. The mean franchise new-car asking price sat 3.29% below MarketCheck MSRP in Sep 2026, against 3.57% in Sep 2025. The median new asking price was $45,030, up from $44,219, and median days on market held at 43.
The docket in Tekion Corp. v. CDK Global LLC
One source describes the grant as partial, so the sources checked do not establish whether any claims remain, and dealer groups mid-negotiation should price that uncertainty into contract length. An appeal, or any claims outside the summary judgment order, would appear on the docket in Tekion Corp. v. CDK Global LLC, No. 24-cv-8879.
How this was measured
Method: US franchise dealer website sales, Sep 2026 against Sep 2025. Sales are listings leaving dealer sites, and prices are asking prices, not transactions. Sep 2026 counts are provisional. Active listings are a Nov 16, 2026 snapshot. MarketCheck data does not measure DMS vendor share.
APIs used:
- MarketCheck Sold Summary API (the get_sold_summary tool in the MarketCheck MCP; docs Sold Summary tool): a national summary for franchise dealers by inventory type, run for Sep 2026 and again for Sep 2025.
- Inventory Search API, GET /v2/search/car/active (Inventory Search API docs): active listings counted by dealer type. No new or used split of active listings is used.
API keys: MarketCheck developer portal
The story we checked
"CDK Global defeats antitrust claims in dealership software dispute", dailyjournal.com, Nov 12, 2026.
Fact-check tally: 3 verified, 2 unverifiable.
- Verified: the summary judgment for CDK Global on the monopolization and attempted monopolization claims.
- Verified: the order came from U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley on Nov 10, 2026.
- Verified: CDK's market share stayed below 50% in 2023 and 2024.
- Unverifiable: that the ruling disposed of all of Tekion's antitrust claims.
- Unverifiable: that the court cited CDK's declining share and Tekion's rapid growth, for which the story is the only source.
You can run the same read in MarketCheck AI Desk: https://ai.marketcheck.com/install
Reproduce this
- search_active_cars: Ask for live dealer listings filtered to franchise dealers to look at the active stock behind the franchise share.
- search_past_90_days: Pull used listings that left franchise dealer websites in the last 90 days and read their last asking prices and miles.
- generate_market_movers: Run it for your own US metro to see what is moving there.
The story we checkedCDK Global defeats antitrust claims in dealership software dispute, dailyjournal.com, Nov 12, 2026
More stories
Cars.com's new product chief inherits a used market selling 2% more, but slower
Cars.com hired a new Chief Product Officer as US used dealer sales rose 2% year on year in Sep 2026 and median days to sell rose to 26.
Nov 16, 2026Week of Nov 16, 2026
Auto Trader's AI inventory push meets a UK used market where 23% of stock has been live 90+ days
MarketCheck data: 137,387 UK used listings, 23.1% of the market, have been live 90+ days, and 61.5% have had a price cut, as Auto Trader builds AI tools.
Nov 9, 2026Week of Nov 9, 2026
J.D. Power's OEM platform arrives as Toyota new sales rise 8% year on year and Chevrolet falls 8%
J.D. Power launched an OEM brand performance platform. MarketCheck data shows Toyota US new sales up 8.5% in Sep 2026 while Ford holds the most stock.
Nov 9, 2026Week of Nov 9, 2026
Reynolds' unified AI agent targets franchise dealers holding 76.3% of US listings; deduplicated data decides it
Reynolds' unified AI agent aims at franchise dealers, 76.3% of US active listings and 2.22 million Sep 2026 sales. Data quality decides results.
Nov 2, 2026Week of Nov 2, 2026
NYC's CarGurus suit makes 'Great Deal' ratings a price claim: rate the fee-inclusive price
NYC's CarGurus lawsuit ties deal ratings to hidden fees. New York used cars ask a median $26,220, 8.1% above the US median, on 108,570 listings.
Oct 26, 2026Week of Oct 26, 2026